Rishabh's response demonstrates a basic understanding of data consolidation using tools like pivot tables and VLOOKUP. However, it lacks depth and structure compared to the benchmark response. Rishabh focuses more on linking data by user ID rather than outlining a comprehensive approach to gather, clean, and standardize data across departments. The response could be improved by detailing steps for ensuring data accuracy, using charts for visualization, and collaborating with department heads to refine the dashboard. This would showcase a more thorough understanding of the task.